Fishbowl Discussion

Fishbowl Discussion

Would you agree that holding classroom discussions on a given topic are easier said than done?  This year in particular, I have found it quite difficult to ensure that students participate in classroom discussions.  The first few months into the school year I realized that it was always the SAME students eager to participate.  Similarly, it was always the SAME students that would choose to stay quiet during discussion.  I knew I had to come up with a solution.

“The single biggest problem in communication is the illusion that it has taken place.”  George Bernard Shaw The quote above really resonated with me and helped me to realize that I really wasn't including everyone in discussion. It was an illusion that communication was taking place but in reality it wasn't happening with everyone. And let’s be realistic, you’re not ALWAYS going to be able to hear from EVERY single student.  However, it was always the same students participating.  I at least knew that something had to be done about that.  What about the rest?  When would I hear from them? Do you also find that certain students dominate classroom discussions?  How do you modify classroom discussions to ensure that the shy ones also get their voices heard?  Or maybe they’re not necessarily shy but perhaps their reasons for not participating as much is that that they need more time to process their thoughts into words.   As educators, it is always our goal to create conditions that enable students with various learning preferences and personalities to contribute their thoughts and ideas.  But this isn’t easy!  Check out the link below to see how you can start implementing a discussion strategy that my students and I have learned to love!  It’s called Fishbowl Discussion. If you click on the following link you will see a fishbowl discussion on why it is important to work in teams. Fishbowl Discussion Let’s ensure that all students engage and participate in class discussion.  As a step into this direction why not try the fishbowl discussion strategy? A fishbowl conversation is a form of dialogue that can be used when discussing topics within large groups.  Although many might use it for the purpose of discussing dilemmas/debates, I have found it useful to utilize this strategy in various ways.  We have used it to discuss the essential questions in Wonders, application problems in Eureka, and even to help gather more ideas in writing.  The advantage of fishbowl discussion is that it allows the entire group to participate in conversation.  Several people can join the discussion while others listen. What does it look like?  Students are separated into an inner and outer circle. In the inner circle, or fishbowl, students have a discussion.  Students in the outer circle listen to the discussion and take notes.  You can preselect those who you want to discuss or you can also just select using equity sticks.  Keep track of those who have been in the inner circle so that next time a different group of students holds the discussion. Or even better, rotate the students around during the discussion so that everyone has an opportunity to talk and to listen on a given topic. I have found it quite interesting to see that the more quiet students finally discuss.  Even if it’s a little bit, at least they’re voice is now being heard.  They feel more accountable and so this pushes them to participate in discussion. You will also start to see that the more you practice this strategy the less you will have to intervene to facilitate discussion.  Before you know it students will be having a conversation right before your eyes and without much scaffolding.   I found the following website quite helpful when it came time for me to plan my discussion: Teaching Strategy: Fishbowl. It explains the process of how to hold a fishbowl discussion in more detail. I hope you find it useful too!   What strategies do you use to help involve all your students in discussion? I'd love to find out! Inspiring Minds, Melissa Hernandez